Gloves come off between new wireless companies

For the past 12 months the fledgling cellular companies that won licences at last year’s spectrum auction have tried to say nice things about each other in public before they launch service. In part that’s because they may need to work together to fight the major carriers.

But that changed Wednesday at a Canadian Telecom Summit panel discussion with three of the newcomers when the spectrum of one was belittled.

It was a claim that suddenly turned the tame debate into a heated fight.

The claim was made by David Dobbin, president of Toronto-based DAVE Wireless against Public Mobile, which surprised onlookers for buying spectrum in the G band of the PCS spectrum.

Many in the industry thought there weren’t any handsets on the market that could operate in that band without expensive modification. That may explain why Public Mobile paid only $52 million for relatively uncontested spectrum covering much of Ontario and Quebec, while most of the bidders, including DAVE Wireless and Globalive Wireless, spent hundreds of millions for spectrum in the safer AWS bands.

In February, Public Mobile demonstrated a working handset that it said had easily been converted to its spectrum, proof its business would be sustainable.

But at Wednesday’s panel discussion for the three new entrants Dobbin announced his company, had a consultant’s report that suggested Public Mobile’s spectrum might be troublesome.

“We see some issues around deployment of those blocks,” he said, without giving details from the report. “It’s spectrum that has not been deployed anywhere else on the planet … There are issues that are going to be a challenge to overcome and may impede the long-term value of anybody deploying it.”

[The report by Montreal telecom consultants Lemay-Yates Associates was e-mailed by DAVE Wireless to the media shortly before the panel started. It said in part that there has been no implementation of service using either the G or the I block of spectrum that and there is no commercialized technology. “Based on information obtained via the FCC (the U.S. Federal Communications Commission), no handsets are presently certified to work in the G Block or the I Block in the US – there is no “ecosystem” or standardization activity to support economies of scale, feature development, roaming, etc.

” ‘Custom’ sets could be developed for G Block or I Block,” the report added, “but would need vendor commitment, new equipment certifications, as well as standardization activities to develop protocols for hand-off, roaming and interworking with other bands. Otherwise the set would be a “Canada-only” with no roaming capabilities and limited commercial value.”]

Until then, the debate between Dobbin, Public Mobile president Alex Krstajic and Globalive Wireless co-chair Anthony Lacavera had been civil, and at times merry. Suddenly the atmosphere was anything but.

Krstajic insisted that “spectrum is spectrum” to all cellphones using the CDMA standard Public Mobile is adopting. “That’s like saying land is land,” retorted Dobbin, pointing out that land in downtown Toronto is more valuable than land in a rural area.

They sparred for several minutes, with Krstajic daring Dobbin to contact CDMA chipmaker Qualcomm for proof it has chipsets for handsets using the G band. Why else would major handset makers such as Samsung, LG and Motorola be offering to sell their handsets to Public Mobile at the same discount they offer other, he asked.

“If I’m wrong, I think you might want to get your money back for that report,” Krstajic said, because Public Mobile would be out of business. “It’s a bit of a lame move to try to re-open this thing,” he told Dobbin about G band allegations, “because here’s the reality: We have our dough. We raised hundreds of millions of dollars … How many pension funds have given you $50 million?” he asked, referring to the investment in Public Mobile by OMERS, the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System.

He accused Dobbin of getting the report to pit the new wireless companies against each other. “No,” replied Dobbin, it was a matter of due diligence. “We commissioned the report because we at some point in the future expect to need more spectrum … We could either get it at the next spectrum auction, or buy you,” he said.

Would you recommend this article?


Thanks for taking the time to let us know what you think of this article!
We'd love to hear your opinion about this or any other story you read in our publication.

Jim Love, Chief Content Officer, IT World Canada

Featured Download

Howard Solomon
Howard Solomon
Currently a freelance writer, I'm the former editor of and Computing Canada. An IT journalist since 1997, I've written for several of ITWC's sister publications including and Computer Dealer News. Before that I was a staff reporter at the Calgary Herald and the Brampton (Ont.) Daily Times. I can be reached at hsolomon [@]

Featured Articles

Empowering the hybrid workforce: how technology can build a better employee experience

Across the country, employees from organizations of all sizes expect flexibility...

What’s behind the best customer experience: How to make it real for your business

The best customer experience – the kind that builds businesses and...

Overcoming the obstacles to optimized operations

Network-driven optimization is a top priority for many Canadian business leaders...

Thriving amid Canada’s tech talent shortage

With today’s tight labour market, rising customer demands, fast-evolving cyber threats...

Staying protected and compliant in an evolving IT landscape

Canadian businesses have changed remarkably and quickly over the last few...

Related Tech News

Tech Jobs

Our experienced team of journalists and bloggers bring you engaging in-depth interviews, videos and content targeted to IT professionals and line-of-business executives.

Tech Companies Hiring Right Now