SHARE
Follow this article on Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Bookmark and Share
Home >> No Category

Sometimes, IT can't win

Sometimes, IT can't win

By:  Chad Dickerson  On: 20 Oct 2003 For: InfoWorld 

You need a thick skin to work in IT because some people will complain about anything. This is because IT sometimes operates in a reality distortion field, where the definition of

You need a thick skin to work in IT because some people will complain about anything. This is because IT sometimes operates in a reality distortion field, where the definition of "success" depends on who you talk to.

The IT staff goes into a major integration projects all wide-eyed and excited. We get to replace cranky old legacy systems with more streamlined systems, thrilled at the prospect of finally retiring the old system and delivering something more usable and productive to end-users. For successful projects, metrics are established early on, and when the project is done, IT reports back to the business side that the goals have been met or exceeded. All objective measurements indicate success, but there's one problem: The end-users hate the system and complain that the old system was better. In a strange twist, the users who hated the old system the most often herald its wonders once it's gone.

I exchanged e-mail recently with a systems manager at a large company who had just finished implementing an industrial application that automated previously manual tasks using a voice recognition system, increasing the employees' productivity. The new system clearly solved the business problem it was intended to solve. But the employees claimed the system was an utter pain. When the system was first implemented, users complained that the voice recognition system slowed them down, but the data proved otherwise -- productivity overall was demonstrably and clearly improved with the new system. A year later, the users still complain that the system slows them down, and the productivity numbers still prove them wrong. In this case, IT is simultaneously the business hero for enabling productivity gains and the employee scapegoat for on-the-job frustrations.

If IT demonstrates clear results on a project, why do anti-IT attitudes persist? IT implementations reflect a larger non-technical business-process change, but IT is often the front-line messenger of such change. Some percentage of employees simply don't like changing the way they do things, and even when better systems are designed and implemented with their input, they steadfastly refuse to concede that a technology implementation was successful. They turn their general anger and frustration toward the new system. In times of uncertainty, there's an easy comfort in hating a new system as the winds of change blow around you.

Frankly, some employees feel under-served and inconvenienced by IT because they simply don't know how to use their computers, and that's not necessarily their fault. Some of the technical frustrations in the enterprise today exist because employees have never been trained on basic Windows usage, for example, much less using a complex CRM or workflow system. Applicants for non-technical positions are rarely screened for the most rudimentary technology skills before they are hired. IT professionals are stretched too thin doing day-to-day IT work to formally train employees; many don't have the temperament for training anyway.


Sign up for our Newsletters












Print |  Views: 665   |   Rating:offoffoffoffoff  (0 votes)
Rate this article on a scale of
1 to 5 stars,5 being the best.




Chad Dickerson Chad Dickerson is a contributor to the International Data Group (IDG) News Service, which publishes global technology stories from bureaus around the world to more than 300 publications in more than 60 countries.

Related Content

A new model for gauging IT success
A new model for gauging IT successThe old model of Return on Investment is inherently flawed. Consultant Greg Duffy suggests a new model, based on the impact of IT investments.
Watch your on-line chit-chat, the boss is reading it
Watch your on-line chit-chat, the boss is reading itBig Brother may not be watching, but your employer most likely is. Every piece of electronic correspondence written and sent from work, from e-mail to instant messages, is something a company has every right to retrieve and read. Businesses are increasingly doing just that, and they're getting into the habit of keeping these electronic records for years.
lawyer, Deeth Williams Wall LLP
lawyer, Deeth Williams Wall LLPEver get that eerie feeling that you're being watched? With Internet monitoring software that allows companies to record employees' online activities throughout the workday, there's a good chance you are. And a recent survey on workplace productivity has given companies 759 billion reasons to adopt such technology.
Blogged down – Why blogs aren’t yet a business buzzword
by joaquim p. menezes - “to blog or not to blog.”
Social networking isn’t just about Facebook
i attended a news conference this morning during which ernst & young llp senior vice-president john graham touched on gartner’s top ten strategic technologies for 2009. going through the list that included virtualization and cloud computing, he came across social networking, at which point he said, “i’m not exactly sure how that contributes entirely to the overall enterprise productivity init
Office attendance forms need an upgrade
i never thought i would miss checkpoint charlie, but i do.a few companies ago, we had a pc set up at a small station near the elevator. this machine r
blog comments powered by Disqus