SHARE
Follow this article on Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Bookmark and Share
Home >> IT Workplace >> Human Resources Issues

on the disparity between skill shortages and the unemployed

on the disparity between skill shortages and the unemployed

By:  Shane Schick  On: 04 Dec 2007 For: ComputerWorld Canada Creator

Bell Canada brings together other vendors and enterprise companies to deal with projected shortfalls in technology succession planning. The Conference Board of Canada offers some preliminary statistics

Nearly two dozen Canadian businesses, led by Bell Canada, have formed an alliance to drive more recruits into the IT industry and fill the more than 58,000 new jobs projected by the Conference Board of Canada for next year.

Bell Canada officially launched the Canadian Coalition for IT Succession during a speech given Tuesday afternoon by Stephane Boisvert, who leads its enterprise group, at the Montreal Board of trade. Other members of the group include vendors such as IBM Canada and Avaya, but also large enterprise firms such as Hydro-Québec, TD Meloche Monnex and CN Rail.

The coalition is kicking off by commissioning a study of the IT labour market by the Conference Board of Canada, which estimates about 1,000 of the 58,000 technology jobs opening up over the next several years will be replacement positions.

Michael Bloom, the Conference Board’s executive director of strategic projects, said if these jobs are not filled they will have a negative economic impact amounting to $10.6 billion a year.

“The unemployment rate for IT workers is two per cent. The national average is six,” Bloom said. “When you consider some people are coming and going – there’s always people changing jobs – the unemployment rate is almost zero.”

Besides the research, Boisvert said the coalition will be coming up with a list of the IT jobs that have the biggest impact on the economy. He described the list as a repository of information that could be used to help show educational institutions what skills graduates need, and persuade government what jobs should be kept on-shore.

There may be a difference between the national figures and the town or city they’re in.Michael Bloom, Conference Board,>TextThe full report from the Conference Board will be released in January, when the coalition will have another launch in Toronto. Boisvert said Bell was pleasantly surprised by the number of companies getting involved, and that these would soon be organized into executive and advisory councils to work on specific projects.

“We’re giving ourselves the next two months to get organized,” he said.

While labour market experts often talk about a “talent gap” within the IT sector, those seeking employment in IT have complained about the difficulty in finding a job despite months of searching.

“There may be a difference between the national figures and the town or city they’re in. They may be presenting qualifications that are no longer up to date. The skill requirements are changing,” Bloom said. “Overall, I guess the other point to make the people that do have jobs don’t call you. You’re getting a sample based on the disaffected.”


Sign up for our Newsletters
Tags: manager












Print |  Views: 1693   |   Rating:onononoffoff  (2 votes)
Rate this article on a scale of
1 to 5 stars,5 being the best.




Shane Schick Shane Schick is the Editor-in-Chief of IT World Canada. Follow him at Twitter.com/shaneschick, Facebook.com/Shane.Schick.Media or myi.tw/ShaneSchickGoogle.

Related Content

Nokia asks for volunteer quitters
Nokia asks for volunteer quittersStarting next month, the smart phone maker will take applications from employees wanting to leave voluntarily, including those in Canada. Find out who is not eligible
IT workers' confidence sags
IT workers' confidence sagsAmerican IT workers believe the weakening economy will impact their jobs
Skills crunch
Skills crunchWithout a national strategy for skills development, experts worry, Canada will fall further behind.
A new direction for CompTIA in Canada
i along with cdn have always supported comptia, an industry trade association based in a chicago. comptia's a+ certification is basically the gold standard.recently comptia founder john venator went into semi-retirement

Comments (11)

The sky is falling again, is it!
by Paul Stanway 12/17/2007 12:00:00 AMOnce again I read that the ?sky is falling? in the I.T. industry because employers cannot find staff. I have 15 years experience as an IBM mainframe programmer/analyst. I was laid off in mid 2000 when the Y2K projects were completed in my company. Since then, I have NOT been able to find any I.T. work whatsoever! Thinking that IBM mainframe programming was pass?, I went back to school and upgraded my I.T. skills to current technology as an e-commerce/website developer. Still I am not able to find ANY work in the I.T. field. Surprisingly, I get calls from recruiters asking me if I know of anyone that has IBM mainframe programming skills!!!! Whenever I respond that I have those skills, the line goes quiet and they politely say ?we will call you later? and they hang up. End result, I never hear back from these very recruiters that say that they are looking for mainframe programmers. I have not worked in the I.T. field since 2000 but I do have 15 years experience programming on IBM mainframes. How long would it take me to get back up to speed programming Cobol, PL/1, IMS, DB2? It would not take me more than a few days to get myself ?back up to speed? programming in these languages. What I am hearing is that employers would rather have unfilled opening for weeks on end instead of hiring someone that would take at most a week ?get up to speed?. I live near Toronto and I would be more than happy to hear from recruiters that are looking from IBM mainframe programmer/analysts in the Greater Toronto area. I would be happy to send you with a copy of my resume. Please feel free to contact me at paulstanwayjr@hotmail.com
IT Site Services Tech
by Andy Johnston 1/2/2008 12:00:00 AMWhile it's true that some people have had negative experiences, there's another side as well. I graduated in 2003, and started immediately in a government position making in excess of $40K. Now (2008 as of the time I'm writing this) almost five years have passed, and even though I'm in the exact same position, my salary has increased by just short of $15k. The opportunities are there for those willing to invest some time and energy, and not allow their expectations to be overly inflated.
There is no shortage of IT workers
by IT Porfessional 12/17/2007 12:00:00 AMIf there is a shortage of IT workers, then why is it so difficult for recent grads, new Canadians and workers over age 40 to get good paying IT employment? The answer: There is no shortage of IT workers and there never will be. The notion of a shortage is an invention by colleges and universities to drive up enrolment in their IT programs. Corporations such as Bell would surely support this drive as it eventually floods the market with more IT talent, ultimately driving down employee costs. Anyone planning to enrol in an IT program with the intention of building a career in IT is making a huge mistake. They can look forward to a lifetime of no job stability and multiple layoffs. Getting started in the industry as an IT professional can be a daunting task without the required experience, as any recent grad knows. I'll concede there might be a bit of a shortage for IT workers ? for those in their prime (early thirties with about seven to ten years experience) who are highly skilled and willing to work enormous amounts of hours for low wages. After that, things become dismal. Virtually no company wants to hire an IT professional over age 40, with their high wages and family obligations. Factor in IT outsourcing to places like China and India, with their vast multitudes of IT workers, and you can quickly see that there is actually a global surplus of IT talent, not a shortage.
IT Manager
by Joe 12/10/2007 12:00:00 AMWhat a farce (58,000 jobs). These inflated numbers are obviously propaganda to lax immigration rules in regards to bringing in 'IT Specialists' from other countries in hopes of lowering salary levels. 3 years removed from an IT major in university and I'm at 30k/year.
Sr. Systems Analyst
by Jimmy407 12/10/2007 12:00:00 AMI think 'High Level Tech' skills is the key here... look into VMware, Citrix, SAP, PMP, Win 2003 Server and other hot skills are required for 50k + jobs. You have to spend money to make money. I have been consulting for last 7yrs .........my 2Cents.
Senior Informatics Specialist
by Pierre Laframboise 12/5/2007 12:00:00 AMOne thing both the private and public sector can do to strenghten our economy in the long run is leverage technology to decentralize some of there staff and take advantage of the untapped human resources, industrial land and lower operating costs in own secondary cities and towns in Canada. Many workers prefer not to go to the big city to get a job. I see municipalities within major transportation corridors that have empty business parks ready for building, lower taxes, affordable housing, excellent educational institutions, good infrastucture, and last but not least people who may consider a career in IT if they did not have to move to the big city. There is no need to outsource out of the country where the quality of work and opportunties for investment are higher risks than at home. You can just immagine if the federal government moved more of it's department headquarters to a city like Kingston the 1st capital of Canada. Still close to Ottawa, but much less conjested than Ottawa. Even large companies like IBM could save money by relocating some of their IT operations and support to smaller communities, without sacrificing easy access to the economic engines of Toronto, Ottawa, and Montreal, not to mention our neighbours to the south. For example in my own neck of the woods there is Cornwall, Brockville, Cardinal, Prescott, and Loyalist Township. Great people, and great places to live, work and play.
IT Analyst (in theory)
by Sean Henley 12/10/2007 12:00:00 AMI also have decades of experience in the IT field and have to agree with Gerry Lowry. I ran Mainframe computers in a 'Cobol-type environment' for 10 years. Since then I have retrained myself on PC's, Servers and modern Networks including a 2 year Post Graduate computer Web Analyst course at Fanshawe College when I was 40 years old. In the IT Industry you have to stay on top of all the new technology that's out there as well as what's on the horizon. Although I have been a Systems Analyst and sold computers and computer components for many years, it seems that in London Ontario the only job I seem to be able to attain is a job in a call center for $12.00 an hour. I would never recommend anyone to go into the IT Industry with all the ups and downs as well as the geographical disparities. As far as personalities go, I am a seasoned Customer Service professional and customers as well as coworkers love dealing and working with me. I lived in Toronto for many years and never had trouble finding a good job, but I have to agree that outside of Toronto it seems to be a dismal future for people like myself. I would even be willing to relocate for a good job with the exception of moving to Toronto, so where do I line up for one of these 58,000 jobs? Please feel free to contact me as I would be happy to supply you with a copy of my resume to back up my career and education at shenley@golden.net
Time to quit or fight?
by Disappointed Canadian 12/12/2007 12:00:00 AMWe are already out of time folks! The tidal wave of change is drowning any chance of reprieve. Outsourcing will continue to bleed the talent pool dry. If you want a job, then send your resume outside of Canada and hope that somebody abroad won't discriminate against you. Some people coming to Canada were discriminated against. Their numbers were low a while ago. Many more now are in Canada and the tables are turning. The Canadian economy will do fine without our truly Canadian talent. Upper management today is in survival mode. New management today has no clue or care for innovation. Only interested in quick and dirty to move up to the next rung. They do not have time to begin understanding the value lost by their actions. The IT talent today is viewed as shareware. The discussions on the internet about IT talent needed are just noise to open doors for more jobs outside Canada. With the acceptance of open source, international computer connections, and other ways of doing our job for less the impression has been deeply ingrained that talent is just a phone call away in the cheapest country. I like the thought that companies are spending effort to get more up to date IT skills taught in the schools. International students are going to love that Canada is taking such a proactive roll to making them stronger. In the future if you cannot speak languages other than English and French how far do you think you will go? The Universities today offer courses in international business. So they are already preparing the students graduating today to get IT resources outside of Canada. Wake up Canada! There will not be a shortage of IT talent as it will flood in from other countries with the people either working here or in their own country. The desk no longer needs to be in Canada. Some of it is our own fault. All businesses looking for cheap labor have given the power over to other countries. They sent people to train them. Now the strength they gain
what is an I.T. job, where are these jobs advertised, what level, what wage levels?
by gerry lowry 12/5/2007 12:00:00 AMis the she/he running the help desk for the corporate line of business application actually an I.T. job? or is it simply a training position that in pre 'PC on every desk' days would have been seen as simply an end-user support role and not as an I.T. position? I ask questions like this because articles like 'IT sector races to fill 58,000 new jobs in 2008' are extremely fluffy ... if I were looking at I.T. as a career option today, without more information, I'd consider another career. Why? Programmer jobs can migrate in a flash to India or China. PC support jobs often pay poorly and are requiring less expertise as operating systems and applications improve in quality. As a computer consultant with decades of experience, I have failed to notice the majority of the 58 thousand jobs mentioned. Examples: a search today of workopolis for all I.T. jobs in Canada returned only 370 results. Dropping 'I.T.' and instead selecting all workopolis computer categories simply stated 'over 500 jobs were found'. Selecting 'Computers-Software' also revealed over 500 jobs were found. BTW, this over 500 jobs limit is a downside ... some web development team has decided which 500 jobs to show the job seeker while hiding the remainder in a black cyberspace hole. There appear to be over 500 Oracle jobs. 135 of these appear to be also consulting positions. Strangely, but not surprisingly, using the 'workopolis NEW SmartSearch' and searching 'consulting' with 'Information Technology' revealed only 89 positions. Perhaps that's the NEW math? I do hope the next article on this topic will be substantially more informative. regards, gerry lowry wasaga beach, ontario gerry.lowry@abilitybusinesscomputerservices.com
Sales Support
by may 12/5/2007 12:00:00 AMThe IT jobs that are available are those which require advanced skills(recent grads need not apply). It is a case of many companies chasing a few candidates. I worked for a software company for a year, as a job developer for a technical college for 10 years and now for an IT consulting company for almost 4 years.
Professor,School of Information Technology Durham College
by Paul Sheehan 12/5/2007 12:00:00 AMAlthough Gerry is correct in stating many IT jobs are not readily advertised I disagree with his slant on the entire IT sector view. As an educator and part time consultant I see many companies in dire need of IT support staff. Typically employment postings do not appear to the public since there is such a high demand to fill that position. Most of these are either filled internally with a friend of an employee, by recommendation of another IT professional or if they do make it to the ad agencies do not last more than a week on the market. As a facilitator, our program has enjoyed a graduate placement rate in excess of 90% for th past 3 years and this is in their related field. Albeit the student can be the most IT savvy individual but if their interpersonal skills are not at par with industry expectations they will fail miserably. I always recommend to my students; if you feel strongly about working for a specific firm, volunteer your services for a month at no charge to the employer. This way they see you are serious and at the same time you have a chance to evaluate the company as a good fit for you. After all it is not only an investment on your part but also for the company taking a gamble on you.
Name: (required) eMail: (optional)

Your email address will not appear online and will be used only if the editor wishes to contact you personally for additional comments.