Jury awards US$147 million in patent dispute over wireless device management. The trial judge still has to make certain rulings that might impact the verdict

RIM rapped by California jury
BANGALORE - A jury in California has found Research In Motion infringed a patent relating to wireless device management owned by assignment by Mformation Technologies, a mobile device management technology provider in Edison, New Jersey.

The jury awarded Mformation US$147.2 million dollars in damages based on past sales in the U.S. of BlackBerry smartphones, connected to the BlackBerry Enterprise Server from late 2008, when the lawsuit was filed, through the trial date, Mformation said on Saturday.

The jury decided that US$8 per unit was reasonable royalty to be paid to Mformation for 18.4 million units sold, according to court documents. The award does not include future royalties, sales to the U.S. government and sales outside the U.S., Mformation said.

RELATED CONTENT
RIM shareholders show their discomfort

In a lawsuit before the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, Mformation had accused RIM of violation of U.S. patent 6,970,917 (’917 patent) titled “system and method for remote control and management of wireless devices,” which was filed for in 2001.

RIM said in a statement on Saturday that it has learned of the jury verdict and “is disappointed by the outcome and is evaluating all legal options.” The trial judge has yet to decide certain legal issues that might impact the verdict, and RIM will await those rulings before deciding whether to pursue an appeal, it added.

The company said it does not believe that the Mformation patent in question is valid.

Mformation’s attorney said the legal system allows small businesses to protect their patented inventions against unauthorized use by large corporations.

The decision by the jury is likely to add to RIM’s woes, including the delay of a key update, BlackBerry 10, to the first quarter of 2013.

The company which faces competition from Apple and phones running Android saw revenue drop in the quarter ended June 2 to US$2.8 billion from US$4.9 billion a year earlier. It also reported a net loss of US$518 million, against a profit of US$695 million a year earlier.

Related Download
Pushing the frontiers - CFO Insights from the Global C-suite Study Sponsor: IBM Canada Ltd
Pushing the frontiers – CFO Insights from the Global C-suite Study
Based on a global survey of 576 CFO interviews, this whitepaper from IBM's Institute for Business Value provides analytical insights into the traits of leading CFOs and what they are doing to become more efficient, forward-looking and proficient at creating profitable growth.
Register Now
Share on LinkedIn Share with Google+ Comment on this article